• 0 Posts
  • 24 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: November 28th, 2023

help-circle


  • Yep! I agree. And I believe the whole discussion is unnecessary in most cases.

    There are some instances where it is important.

    Do you cut the red or the blue wire when defusing a bomb (a clear definition is mandatory!)

    Who can participate in the women’s sport competition and who in the men’s (this conversation should be done by the people who are actually doing the sport, not by me!)

    Should I as a boss apply a gender pay gap to you or not?


  • If it changes by culture, then each culture will have their own definition. So if we ask a Texan Redneck and a Swedish Librarian, we will get two very different answers. But they both might be right in their culture.

    Culture does not have borders. You and your neighbour have different cultures. So I believe this is nothing you can argue about, unless you specify a definition first. It does not have to be a global definition, it does not have to apply to all people, it doesn’t even have to make sense.

    The definition will make it possible to discuss the topic. When the definition is precise, it will be a very short discussion. The interesting part is coming up with that definition and figuring out what aspects you want to include and what you deem not relevant.


  • I don’t know any person like this so this is just my imagination guessing:

    Could be that you were born with male phenotype and raised that way. But you discovered that your feelings are really more aligned with the feminine realm.

    But since you look male you don’t want to appear strange for others, so you keep the way you have been looking all your life, how you are used to dress and behave, and just identify as female. Might make you feel better and more aligned with your inner self.


  • We could define two genders: Males are all humans larger than 175 cm Females are all that are 175cm or smaller.

    Or we take the degree by what the jaw line is curved and sort it from most masculine with strong curves to most feminine with slow elegant curves.

    We could go by genetics. Then we only have a handful of genders (xx, xy, xyy, xxy, … etc)

    What I am saying is: define what it is first, and then the discussion is very simple. By my first definition there are exactly two genders, second one has infinite, third definition has a handful of genders.