• 1 Post
  • 101 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 14th, 2023

help-circle













  • Fair point. My point would be that English doesn’t really inflect words at all, but when it does, namely pronouns, it has both cases and genders.

    For comparison, in German, cases don’t change nouns either (except some genitives - kinda like English, now that i think about it), they instead affect articles, and even then the nominative and accusative case are identical, except for masculine singular nouns, and first and second person pronouns. So, if n. and f. nouns dominate, you could make the case that German doesn’t have an acc. case, and then make a carveout for m. noun “outliers”. Except step into first and second person, and acc. pops back out, meaning it was always there, even for f. and n.


  • Aqarius@lemmy.worldtoMicroblog Memes@lemmy.worldJust Classicist Problems
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    24 days ago

    “Some feminitives” is disingenuous. It’s an Indo-European language, it shares the structure of other IE languages, in some cases pared down and/or in disuse, but they’re still there, same as vestigial base-12 counting.

    I don’t get why people are so upset about the concept of grammatical gender, though. It’s gramatical, it’s not actual gender - original division in PIE was “animate” and “inanimate”. Hell, I vaguely remember a conlang that had separate genders for terrestrial and aquatic animals, so you could absolutely make one that has a gender for “wolf”.


  • Aqarius@lemmy.worldtoMicroblog Memes@lemmy.worldJust Classicist Problems
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    24 days ago

    Well, uh, yes. The thread OP notes greek (as in bible) uses generic masculine forms for plural. Modern English takes that tack much more broadly, using the theoretically masculine term for everything. And you can tell it’s masculine, not neuter, because, eg. a steward (of Gondor) is a steward, but a (-n air) stewardess is now a flight attendant.


  • Aqarius@lemmy.worldtoMicroblog Memes@lemmy.worldJust Classicist Problems
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    24 days ago

    Being immediately identifiable isn’t the standard, for example in languages that don’t use the definite article (Slavic languages, for example) the first noun wouldn’t necessarily exhibit it’s grammatical gender, but it wouldn’t mean it doesn’t have one. Also, the brackets you used get parsed by boost as html tags.

    The very existence of gendered nouns and pronouns means English has gender. It’s just less noticeable because unlike the German “-innen” approach, English typically shoves most things into neuter and mostly defaults to male for persons and then hides it behind “he or she” or a singular “they”. You can argue it’s archaic or vestigial, and I’d agree, but it is there. Same how nouns don’t exhibit cases, but pronouns do. Compare:

    “The man stood there, the man’s hand on the coffee cup, the cup warming the man”.

    “He stood there, his hand on the coffee cup, the cup warming him.”